Haley can't seem to choose between her past and present relationships and is forced to make a decision. Meanwhile, Manny returns to college and dorm life while his girlfriend, Sherry, continues to stay at Jay and Gloria's, and might be overstaying her welcome.

Rate this episode

Guest Stars: Chris Geere as Professor Arvin Fennerman, Reid Ewing as Dylan, Marcello Reyes as Cal, Hillary Ann Matthews as Sherry

Writers: Jeff Richman, Danny Zuker

Director: Beth McCarthy Miller